Exit, voice or loyalty – what matters most in building online communities?

Michael Harris /   June 29, 2015 at 8:31 PM 2,737 views

We’re creating a platform for people who use and provide public and voluntary services to inform better social policy. For this to be a place they want to come to, and invest time and energy in, it will have to feel like – it will have to be – their community. How can we ensure that our community becomes theirs? The answer lies in an essay published more than 40 years ago. The Guardian has been running an interesting series of articles this week on the ‘battle for the internet‘. Wednesday’s articles considered the growth of ‘walled gardens‘ such as Facebook and iTunes. The usefulness and increasing ubiquity of these privately-owned ‘public squares’ raises important privacy, censorship and accessibility issues. These might not matter much to most of us, most of the time, but they still matter – both personally (for example, when they use our data in a way we didn’t anticipate) and politically (given the economic, social and cultural power such companies now wield). This has led some commentators to suggest that these platforms are effectively public utilities and should be regulated as such, but this (highly unlikely) proposition has only been put forward because of our lack of influence, as ordinary users, over how these platforms operate and what their policies are. The only way we can really hope to influence how they act is to leave (with all of the obvious downsides of doing so). This is the ‘exit’ option described in Albert Hirschman’s oft-cited 1970 essay Exit, Voice, and Loyalty. Facebook’s owners – which could be you if you’re intending to buy some of their shares – must at some level exist in a perpetual state of fear that their users can simply up sticks, and in this way the threat of exit is a powerful driver for improvement. It leads to new features, better services etc – indeed it’s the basis of free and competitive markets. But this doesn’t make these communities ours – quite the opposite, it distances us from them. Exit isn’t the only ‘option’ we want in relation to the communities of which we’re part. This is why Hirschman notes that, in addition to leaving, people can try to use their ‘voice’, that is they can attempt to repair or improve matters through communicating their problem and/or proposing a solution. What’s clear, thought about in this way, is that platforms like Facebook are highly unlikely to listen to our views unless they are accompanied by the threat of exit. We can judge this because Facebook et al. have  failed (or haven’t cared) to develop mechanisms and processes by which we can effectively express our voice and influence how they operate. Hirschman suggests there’s a third factor at play, which is loyalty. This can slow exit (for example, people feel very strongly attached to a particular brand), but perhaps only for a time. Loyalty can drive people to use their voice – to suggest changing things and improving them, so that they aren’t forced to exit. You’re more likely to use your voice if you have some degree of loyalty to a community, institution or company – otherwise why would you bother? Hirschman’s model, though in one sense pretty simple, is the kind of idea that once you read about it sticks with you and you find yourself applying to all sorts of situations (which of the three aspects of it you think matters the most can also suggest a particular political persuasion). My own view is that exit matters – a lot. If you don’t like something, show how you feel. If you want to use a social network that doesn’t own all your data, then support the development of Diaspora. If you don’t like Microsoft’s (often tardy) programs, choose open source software (like we’ll be doing for our demo platform). If you’re tired of being prompted and pushed around by iTunes, use another music player. And if you want to support the development of a new way of creating better social policy in a community that you shape – if you want to break down the ‘walled garden’ that is most policymaking – then watch this space. But surely a better way to build and retain a community – and so strengthen loyalty – is to enable and encourage people to exercise their voice. It’s this that ultimately determines the health and sustainability of (online) communities, because it determines the extent to which people feel that they own a community. It may be less tangible, but it’s much more meaningful, than holding a few hundred shares out of a few million. In this spirit, I’d be interested in what you think about what makes communities work – what attracts you to them, and why you stay.

13 thoughts on “Exit, voice or loyalty – what matters most in building online communities?”

  1. Mariano says:

    Hey, you used to write fantastic, but the last several posts have been kinda boring… I miss your great writings. Past several posts are just a little out of track! come on!

    http://www.closefans.com/blog/24601/think-about-pest-controls/

  2. vshare download iphone says:

    I am seriously enjoying the design of your site. Do you run into any kind of web browser compatibility troubles? A lot of my own site audience have complained about my vshare download free site not operating effectively in Explorer yet looks amazing in Firefox. Have you got any solutions to assist correct this situation?

    http://cristoparatodaslasnaciones.com/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=user&id=756774

  3. vshare download ios says:

    I just arrived over here from a different web address relating to vshare for android and thought I might as well check out this page. I quite like the things I see so I am just following you. Looking towards looking into the site yet again.

    http://hsepeoplejobs.com/members/george68loaf/activity/177468/

  4. useful content says:

    Hi! This is my first comment on your site so I just wanted to give a fast shout out and tell you I truly enjoy reading through your blog posts. Can you suggest any other sites which go over shareit app download? I’m likewise really hooked on that thing! Thanks!

    http://www.aracne.biz/index.php?option=com_k2&view=itemlist&task=user&id=652285

  5. inspirational quotes says:

    We really adore your site and find many of your content to be exactly I am trying to find. Do you offer guest writers to post information for you? I wouldn’t mind writing a post regarding love quotes or even on most of the topics you’re posting about on this website. Nice page!

    http://hometown.scau.edu.cn/bbs/home.php?mod=space&uid=654614

  6. http 192.168 1.1 says:

    Howdy can you let me know which blogging platform you are using? I’m looking to start out my blog on internet router in the future yet I’m having a hard time making the decision.

    http://www.unioncountyga.gov/ActivityFeed/MyProfile/tabid/61/UserId/36874/Default.aspx

  7. oval trampolines says:

    Somebody essentially help to make seriously posts I would state. This is the very first time I frequented your website page and thus far? I surprised with the research you made to create this particular publish incredible. Magnificent job!

    https://palmnavarro70lonpjk.kroogi.com/en/content/3354167-The-Super-Article-To-Understand-More-On-Mini-Trampoline.html

  8. facetime for android says:

    We totally like your blog and find a lot of the content to be exactly I am searching for. Do you offer guest writers to write material for you? I wouldn’t mind producing an article about facetime free or maybe on a lot of the topics you write about on this website. Nice internet site!

    http://www.machine777sous.com/index.php?task=profile&id=286029

  9. download shareit for pc says:

    Thank you very much for discussing the idea, I saved this webpage. I’m also in search of material on shareit app download, do you know where I can come across a thing like that? I’ll be back soon!

    https://klemmensenmueller55jbivpu.kroogi.com/en/content/3360398-and-65279-SHAREit-For-COMPUTER-Download-and-install-Windows-7.html

  10. Rubi says:

    hey there and thank you for your info – I have certainly picked up something new from right here. I did however expertise several technical points using this web site, since I experienced to reload the site a lot of times previous to I could get it to load correctly. I had been wondering if your web host is OK? Not that I’m complaining, but slow loading instances times will often affect your placement in google and could damage your high-quality score if advertising and marketing with Adwords. Anyway I am adding this RSS to my e-mail and can look out for much more of your respective exciting content. Ensure that you update this again very soon..

    http://www.purevolume.com/gibsonu340/posts/13968152/Video+Surveillance+Systems+Strategies+For+You

  11. attractwomenbooks says:

    Hello, what do you think around how to attract females? Extremely interesting matter, isn’t it?

    http://cashpngy616blog.blogdigy.com/tips-on-how-to-entice-ladies-your-mindset-is-the-key-3480659

  12. find more info says:

    There’s terrific upgrades on the layout of the page, I honestly enjoy that! My site is about mobile number locator and currently there are a lot of things to be done, I’m yet still a novice in internet site design. Be careful!

    http://svetisavaflemington.org/members/egghand55/activity/356200/

  13. Chester says:

    Hi, I think your site might be having browser compatibility issues. When I look at your website in Opera, it looks fine but when opening in Internet Explorer, it has some overlapping. I just wanted to give you a quick heads up! Other then that, fantastic blog!

    http://fredm21737.skyrock.com/3282153122-Online-Reputation-Management-Services-Story.html

Please comment with your real name using good manners.

Leave a Reply