From the archive: Needed – a new language for tax and spend

Red Brick /   February 5, 2013 at 8:33 PM 2,460 views

Alan Johnson MP’s interview with Progress covered a lot of topics, including the future of trades unionism, but it was his comment about public spending that attracted my attention.

Let’s look at what was actually said in the Progress piece:

Asked whether Labour should commit to stick to the government’s spending limits for its first two years in office – as it did in 1997 – Johnson says it is ‘difficult to think what else you can do’. ‘We can’t get away from the fact that the fiscal deficit has got to come down,’ he argues.

Johnson is a sophisticated political thinker, even if I don’t always agree with his conclusions. But throwaway remarks like this, and he isn’t alone in saying it, are unhelpful, because we have to challenge conventional thinking about public spending and, in particular, public borrowing to fund investment.

The oft-quoted example of Labour accepting the Tory spending plans for 2 years after 1997 to establish its credentials (remember prudence?) doesn’t work for me. The Tories as much as admitted that Kenneth Clarke’s proposed spending cuts were designed to make it look as if his tax cut promises for the election were affordable: they wouldn’t have stuck to the spending limits if they had won. Especially in relation to housing, accepting the Tory budgets set Labour on a bad course and a failure to build affordable homes that was not really overcome until 2008.

The position in 2015 will be very different from 1997. By 2015 it is likely that output will hardly be any higher than 2008, we may have had the triple dip, and the economy will still be running seriously under-capacity. Most people will be poorer and some people will be a huge amount poorer, especially those who were the poorest to start with. Services across the board will have been decimated and needs will have increased significantly. The housing crisis will have intensified even more, with homelessness rising rapidly and rents becoming increasingly unaffordable along with energy costs, travel costs and other basics.

To have policies fit for the circumstances Labour will need a radical new approach to tax and spend. Contrary to what Alan Johnson said, it is relatively easy ‘to think of what else you could do’. Ed Miliband’s notion of ‘pre-distribution’ caused some mirth (helpful explanations here) but is a vital concept in rebalancing public spending to limit the cost to the taxpayer of market failures. For example, the idea of the ‘Living Wage’ resonates with people and is being taken up by a wide range of progressive employers, cutting the cost of income support. The super-rich and mega-corporations have to pay their taxes and some new taxes (eg on the super-heated central London property market) will be justified. The banks carry on regardless and are still not paying for the profit-driven recklessness that caused the collapse. Income and wealth inequality is greater than it has been for decades.

In housing, far from being ‘out of control’ the housing benefit bill is the direct consequence of policy decisions (eg not building social housing, dumping homeless people in the private rented sector) and the financial crisis (unaffordable home ownership leading to ‘generation rent’). Building social rented housing and limiting private rent increases would help bring it down. Housing investment pretty much pays for itself through increased taxes and reduced unemployment. Better accounting practice across departments would allow investment in housing to be measured through savings in health and other budgets. And, as we have argued before, changes to Treasury conventions, to bring the UK in line with international practice, could enable the public corporate sector to borrow prudentially and be much more productive.

There are many more ideas around. But we are still a long way from a General Election and the point where the Labour Opposition has to make promises and detail its tax and spending plans. In housing we already have some bankable commitments, notably the promise to fund 125,000 extra affordable homes (of which 40,000 would be social rent) through the bankers bonus tax and the sale of G4 licences. But at this stage it is vital to challenge conventional views of public spending and the one-dimensional logic that the deficit can only be reduced through cuts in public services: it can equally well be reduced by a mix of policies on pre-distribution, reduced tax avoidance, targeted tax rises, and the promotion of growth and investment.

Just like challenging the dominance of the ‘scrounger’ narrative, this is another area where using the right language consistently will reap political benefits.

Courtesy of @stevehilditch and @labourhousing via Red Brick


10 thoughts on “From the archive: Needed – a new language for tax and spend”

  1. zephyrol says:

    Felicito, que palabras adecuadas…, la idea brillante

  2. shenequaol says:

    Thanks for your useful post. Through the years, I have come to be able to understand that the actual symptoms of mesothelioma are caused by the build up of fluid involving the lining on the lung and the torso cavity. The sickness may start while in the chest spot and propagate to other areas of the body. Other symptoms of pleural mesothelioma include weight loss, severe inhaling and exhaling trouble, temperature, difficulty eating, and bloating of the neck and face areas. It needs to be noted that some people existing with the disease tend not to experience every serious signs or symptoms at all.

  3. markol says:

    Thanks for the diverse tips contributed on this blog. I have observed that many insurers offer clients generous discounts if they decide to insure several cars with them. A significant volume of households currently have several cars these days, specially those with more mature teenage young children still located at home, along with the savings with policies can soon begin. So it pays off to look for a great deal.

  4. justdoit says:

    asiatische showcase becomes richness

    SINGAPORE (Reuters everyday life!) lots of people are elegant?

    Singapore’s asian kitchenware cultures adult ed strives of identify the entire [url=]ChnLove[/url] deep belief in an important display that generates eyesight goodies or even inspiration invoking screens covering anything from barbie barbies olden items dating back 2,200 long ago.

    “The quest to accentuate ‘s been around in the human psyche right from the start of time and each tradition and time had its own conditions to get good looks. This is because difficult as soon as possible as this became centuries earlier, my wife shared with Reuters.

    The convention ingested two weeks and weeks design and furthermore presents a small amount of 300 things, the majority of coming from your museum’s vaults which are being examined by you for the first time.

    sentiments between Hindi passion poet Bihari this “Satasai” (Seven Hundred vs,compared to the) fame, established a bad tone: “absolutely nothing gorgeous while well as horrible inside of it; cosmetic lies in the beholder’s eyesight. a more some thing gets, those lovelier seems,

    when longstanding nationalities, atmosphere is connected to male fertility and then expecting mothers by their rotund waistlines ample figure became thought of apex the amongst lovely. that organizations were additional polished, each notions together with natural influenced.

    flabby has been cool

    a good of giving shape are unquestionably fabulous stays for a few centuries in asia, in areas this popular in just [url=][/url] figurines e. g,together with “excessive lovely lady” as to China’s 9th century Tang empire and so an 11th century bronze Uma Parameshvari, any kind of Hindu momma goddess, could be the exhibition’s superstar expose.

    products unwanted unknown became in vogue and willowy a lot of women had become the expectations in order for benefit, actually compared with yesterday.

    you see, the exhibition created up of numerous modern championship associated nature and culture, regarding fernrrstliche and as a consequence point style paper blankets that includes absolutely exact looking for, Airbrushed celebrities and even captions of exhquite possiblyt site visitors to manage your weight clothe more effective.

    the most important the queen’s the let pass Singapore rubber stamps to use decanter or wineglass box and so barbie toys Bratz figurines modern a modern day add touching gallery expectation may attracts little followers.

    all the gallery provides you with various involved features, incorporating a touch screen that helps you customizing a [url=][/url] take on toward your own house ideal beauty care and one written in which discusses tattooing as it’s watched courtesy of – artisans the actual targeted visitors.

    the most [url=][/url] popular tvs are based in the “pursuit of attractiveness” sector, with its shining american native necklace, subtle Peranakan natural powder cartons and as well as normal pet grooming eating utensils resembling longstanding bloodstream scrubbers filigreed rosewater sprinklers.

    and the reveal quite possibly is focused on the down side of that look for, demonstrating the light weight aluminum for instance displayed through process of a small number of fernrrstliche tribes to elongate personal necks along with bit of position and mutilated extremities akin to chinese language language ladies who boundarie buy them feet to “Dainty,

    Krishnan pointed out your was also ready to spotlight one particular cookware idea of “internal” or even “psychic” appeal of an integral part of the region’s Hindu furthermore Buddhist customs and also the counterfoil to receive, devoid of having which usually it would not survive.

    “natural glory doesn’t necessarily occur when it comes to isolation, and contact us by calling their own antithesis unpleasant over convenience’s reason, the wife says. “instances aesthetic is actually horrid with regards to comprises of internal vice.

  5. drumsol says:

    Today, while I was at work, my cousin stole my apple ipad and tested to see if it can survive a 40 foot drop, just so she can be a youtube sensation. My apple ipad is now destroyed and she has 83 views. I know this is completely off topic but I had to share it with someone!

  6. Sacs 脿 main hermes birkin femmes prix says:

    I’m in sartorial heaven! I wore an almost exact replica of her outfit yesterday, same blue tux tunic from jcrew. here I am seeing it photographed. Shame I didn’t have Kate with me too*
    Sacs 脿 main hermes birkin femmes prix

  7. fake love necklaces for women says:

    I’m not sure where you are getting your info, but great topic. I needs to spend some time learning more or understanding more. Thanks for wonderful info I was looking for this info for my mission.
    fake love necklaces for women

  8. fake love chain necklace says:

    The contemporary Zune browser is shockingly Excellent, but not as favourable as the iPod’s. It performs well, however is not as immediate as Safari, and incorporates a clunkier interface. If by yourself sometimes program upon employing the website browser that’s not an issue, still if you are coming up with to browse the world wide web alot against your PMP then the iPod’s larger exhibit and much better browser may possibly be sizeable.
    fake love chain necklace

  9. imitation bracelet or gris says:

    Hello there. I discovered your blog by means of Google even as searching for a comparable subject, your site got here up. It seems to be great. I’ve bookmarked it in my google bookmarks to visit then.
    imitation bracelet or gris

  10. copia love bracciale cartier says:

    Good day! I just bineoris want to give a huge thumbs up for the nice data you could have right here on this post. I might be coming again to your blog for more soon.
    copia love bracciale cartier

Please comment with your real name using good manners.

Leave a Reply