The Sun and mental health – that front page

The Masked AMHP /   June 29, 2015 at 8:37 PM 2,816 views

The Sun’s full page headline today (7th October 2013) states baldly “1,200 killed by mental patients”. The number 1,200 is in red letters 2 ½ inches high. In tiny letters to the side of this headline is the admission that this figure was the total over a decade. It’s hard to know where to start in a dissection of this report. That huge red number is clearly intended to alarm. One has to conclude that the Sun wishes to suggest that its readers are all at risk of being murdered in their beds by homicidal maniacs. The Sun’s use of the term “mental patients” is not only deliberate use of a term with pejorative implications, but also implies that there are two sorts of people: “normal” people (Sun readers perhaps?) and “mental” people, people who are unpredictable and potentially dangerous. Having emblazoned its front page with this frightening statement, the Sun’s “full story” is buried on pages 6 and 7. It begins: “A Sun investigation today reveals disturbing failings in Britain’s mental health system that have allowed high-risk patients to kill 1,200 in a decade.” The article is fringed by 12 brief accounts of people who have been murdered by “mental patients” over the last few years. So where did the Sun obtain these figures? It mentions “a Manchester University study”. This can only be the Annual Report The National Confidential Inquiry into Suicideand Homicide by People with Mental Illness, published by the University of  Manchester in July 2013. The Sun’s “probe” (their word), must have taken all of 30 seconds before finding this study, which was published 3 months previously in July. Community Care published a thoughtful article back on 5th July 2013, headlining their article with a quote from the Report saying: “The number of homicides committed by mental health patients has fallen ‘to its lowest level for a decade’.” The writer of this report, Julian Hendy, goes on to express skepticism of some of the figures. The Sun reports that 122 people a year on average were killed by “mental patients”. This would appear to have been lifted from Community Care’s article. The Sun goes on to lay the blame for these figures on “the slashing of budgets for mental health care”. They quote Marjorie Wallace of SANE as saying that “homicide figures may not have increased in decades – but significantly they have not declined either.” So what does the University of Manchesterreport actually say? Right at the beginning of the report, it is stated: “Homicide by mental health patients has fallen substantially since a peak in 2006, and the figures for the most recent confirmed years, 2009-2010, are the lowest since we began data collection in 1997”. Although the report acknowledges that some of its statistics may be incomplete, it does say “it is likely that this is a true fall in patient homicide”. Already, this seems to be factually at odds with the Sun’s report. While I do not wish to minimise the potential effects of recent cutbacks to spending on mental health, in this case, recent changes in mental health legislation and delivery are given as a possible explanation for this reduction, citing the use of CTO’s as a potential factor. Another failing of the Sun’s “probe” is to place these figures in any sort of context. The Office of National Statistics provides illuminating statistics for overall numbers of homicides. It gives statistics going back to 1960 for homicides initially recorded by the police. The long term graph shows a gradual increase in homicides from 282 in 1960 to a peak of 1047 in 2002-3. Since then, there has been a steep fall to around half of that peak. Taking the ONS statistics, it can be seen that during the 10 year period from 2001-2011 on which the Sun bases its figures, there were a total of 7926 homicides. This compares with the figure of 1220 homicides committed by mental health patients quoted by the Sun and Julian Hendy. In other words, a little over 15% of homicides were committed by people who were known patients of mental health services. To put it another way, 85% of murders were committed by people who weren’t “mental patients”. But I suppose the headline: “You’re 6 times more likely to be killed by a “normal” person than someone with mental health problems”doesn’t have quite the same ring to it. Courtesy of The Masked AMHP

24 thoughts on “The Sun and mental health – that front page”

  1. Redondo Marketing says:

    Great post! I’m shocked at how fast your blog loaded on my cell phone. I really appreciate your efforts and I will be waiting for your further post thank you once again. Son of a gun, this is so helpful!

  2. Hermosa Beach says:

    I am continually browsing online for tips that can help me. Thank you! I do take pleasure in writing but it just seems like the first 10 to 15 minutes are usually lost simply just trying to figure out how to begin. First off I would like to say excellent blog!

  3. Jesse Grillo says:

    I’m bored to death at work so I decided to browse your website on my iphone during lunch break. No complaints on this end, simply a good piece.

  4. Beverly PR says:

    Don’t get afraid to spread your thoughts. I’m shocked at how fast your blog loaded on my cell phone. No complaints on this end, simply a good piece. You are a very persuasive writer.

  5. Redondo Beach Marketing says:

    In my view, if all webmasters and bloggers made just right content material as you did, the web might be a lot more helpful than ever before. I have been looking everywhere for this!

  6. Jesse Grillo says:

    Thank you! I enjoy the knowledge you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. Nice write up.

  7. Hermosa Beach Marketing says:

    want hermosa data marketing and brand marketing campaigns plus pinterest?

  8. Redondo Marketing says:

    aids customers, super charging accelerated branding.

  9. perris Cannabis says:

    Well written! I simply stumbled upon your wearticle and wished to mention that I have truly enjoyed surfing around your blog posts. Keep it up!

  10. Redondo Marketing says:

    I am going to follow you on Facebook. Are you a user on Facebook?

  11. West Covina Dispensary says:

    I will bookmark this website. I enjoy the stuff you provide here and can not wait to take a look when I get home. When I opened my phone this website was already loaded. Found this on Blog and I am glad I did

  12. Huntington Beach Weed says:

    Thank you for sharing your info. I bet you make babies smile. Can you tell us more about this? I am on the same side as you. Some nice points there.

  13. new business speaker says:

    You saved me a lot of hassle just now. You have a lot of knowledge on this topic. Neat blog. You should be incredibly proud of yourself. I needed this.

  14. hermosa pr says:

    It is rare to see a nice blog like this one these days. Extremely helpful article.

  15. Chairman adviser says:

    Great post, thanks a lot. I bet you do crossword puzzles in ink. Spot on with this post. I love articles like this one but I find myself spending hours simply browsing and reading. Thank you!

  16. dispensaries says:

    Somehow you make time stop and fly at the same time. That is the thinking of a creative mind. This is so helpful! I was looking everywhere and this popped up like nothing! You could survive a Zombie apocalypse.

  17. cannabis cup says:

    I hate that my phone battery is dying. I appreciate you. My teacher wants to be a teacher in this issue. I will bookmark this.

  18. new business speaker says:

    I bet top Twitter pros would love this. I just discovered your write ups on Monday. Well this is weird, when I opened my lap top this site was loaded.

  19. Jesse Grillo says:

    Nice read. I simply stumbled upon your weposts and wished to mention that I have truly enjoyed surfing around your posts posts. When I started my Iphone this website was already running. Guess I will just book mark this posts. Your creative potential seems limitless.

  20. Huntington Beach Weed says:

    Beyond helpful info. Extremely helpful blogs. I truly think this blog needs much more consideration. I will probably be again to read much more, thanks for that info. You remind me of my dad.

  21. technology adviser says:

    Your page is really useful. magnificent work, keep it up. Incredible! This blog looks just like my old one

  22. mass roots delivery says:

    I discovered your site by chance I have added your page to my Website Kudos.

  23. Jesse Grillo says:

    Your post is absolutely on point! I needed this. I was reading your posts while on a boat. Great tips and very easy to understand.

Please comment with your real name using good manners.

Leave a Reply